Resprouting ability may increase a plant's resistance to recurrent disturbances in aquatic ecosystems. We investigated the effect of mechanical disturbances on survival and regrowth patterns in three clonal aquatic species of similar growth form but with different ecological ranges in terms of flooding (Myriophyllum verticillatum, Myriophyllum spicatum and Potamogeton coloratus). P. coloratus prefers to colonize stable habitats, whereas M. verticillatum occurs in intermediately flooded habitats and M. spicatum is tolerant to a high flooding frequency. Two cutting treatments (single cuts or repeated cuts) were applied under controlled conditions. We hypothesized that M. verticillatum and M. spicatum would be resistant to cutting displaying either a tolerant or an escape strategy whereas P. coloratus would be sensitive to cutting. Our hypothesis was validated, as the three species displayed contrasting responses to disturbance. M. verticillatum displayed efficient clonal propagation following breakage (escape strategy), but its growth rate decreased after recurrent disturbances. P. coloratus displayed a close response but was unable to compensate biomass loss even after one cut. M. spicatum maintained a similar growth rate by developing a densely branched form despite recurrent disturbances but with a low investment in clonal growth (tolerance strategy). Both biomass compensation and clonal propagation influence plant fitness, but their relative advantage differs depending on the flooding frequency experienced by plants in their natural habitats. Clonal propagation may promote recolonization after disturbances in infrequently flooded sites, but seems less efficient than a tolerance strategy for survival in frequently flooded sites.