Terrane accretion and intraplate deformation are both common processes occurring during the assembly of large continental masses. The relative roles of these mechanisms are at the heart of a debate concerning the tectonic evolution of the Borborema Province, northeastern Brazil. In the Central subprovince, four terranes or domains have been proposed. In the Alto Moxotó domain, paragneiss of the Sertânia Complex were considered to record a distinct structural and geochronological evolution compared to those in the adjacent Rio Capibaribe domain, in the East. Here, we report the results of a geological study conducted in the type area of the Sertânia Complex. Kinematic criteria and metamorphic mineral assemblages indicate that the main foliation record top-to-the-W tectonic transport under upper amphibolite facies conditions (650–700 °C). The main foliation was affected by overturned folds and upright to inclined folds; the latter two formed coevally with the development of transcurrent shear zones. Samples of mafic orthogneiss and paragneiss tectonically intercalated in the same outcrop were dated by LA-ICP-MS. The orthogneiss sample yields a crystallization age of 1978 ± 8 Ma. Detrital zircons in the paragneiss sample show a multimodal pattern with a well-defined age peak at c. 700 Ma, showing that the paragneiss is younger than 700 Ma and so the main foliation is also younger than this age. In turn, these findings suggest that the occurrence of exclusively Paleoproterozoic zircons in three other dated samples of paragneiss cannot be used to accurately define the deposition age of the detritus. The structural and geochronological characteristics of the Sertânia Complex are similar to those of the Surubim Complex in the Rio Capibaribe domain. Together with previous results showing that the basement of the Alto Moxotó and Rio Capibaribe domains is also similar, we interpret these sequences as having been deposited on a once contiguous tract of continental crust. An accretionary terrane model is thus not required to account for the tectonic evolution of this portion of the Borborema Province. Instead, a model of intracontinental deformation of a preexistent continent is fully supported by the data and also by the lack of evidence for oceanic subduction.