High density polyethylene films (200 µm) with an initial bimodal chain length distribution were aged in ovens at 60°C, 70°C, and 80°C. Oxidation effects were characterized at the macromolecular scale to measure the chain length distribution, the amount of crystalline phase, the type of crystallites, and the thickness of the amorphous layer. Additionally, mechanical properties were measured using tensile tests. Regardless of the aging temperature, the same behavior was observed: bimodal chain length distribution became unimodal, the crystallinity ratio increased, the amorphous layer thickness decreased, and the polyethylene became brittle. The embrittlement of the polymer is discussed, and two criteria are proposed: a critical molar mass and a critical amorphous layer thickness. The latter appears to be independent of the initial chain length distribution of the polyethylene.