Binaural reproduction aims at recreating a realistic sound scene at the ears of the listener using headphones. Unfortunately, externalization for frontal and rear sources is often poor (virtual sources are perceived inside the head, instead of outside the head). Nevertheless, previous studies have shown that large head-tracked movements could substantially improve externalization and that this improvement persisted once the subject had stopped moving his/her head. The present study investigates the relation between externalization and evoked response potentials (ERPs) by performing behavioral and EEG measurements in the same experimental conditions. Different degrees of externalization were achieved by preceding measurements with 1) head-tracked movements, 2) untracked head movements, and 3) no head movement. Results showed that performing a head movement, whether the head tracking was active or not, increased the amplitude of ERP components after 100 ms, which suggests that preceding head movements alters the auditory processing. Moreover, untracked head movements gave a stronger amplitude on the N1 component, which might be a marker of a consistency break in regards to the real world. While externalization scores were higher after head-tracked movements in the behavioral experiment, no marker of externalization could be found in the EEG results.