“The rest is silence”: Picturing the Unseen in Nutshell - Archive ouverte HAL Accéder directement au contenu
Article Dans Une Revue Polysèmes Année : 2022

“The rest is silence”: Picturing the Unseen in Nutshell

« The rest is silence » : figurer l’invisible dans Nutshell

Résumé

Ian McEwan’s claim that, like Conrad, he writes novels “to make [us] see” can seem problematic when applied to his 2016 novel Nutshell. The novel both illustrates and complicates the author’s self-assigned task, as its foetal narrator is essentially blind but still insists on conveying a view of the world outside the womb. It is further complicated by the fact that Nutshell is meant as a retelling of Shakespeare’s Hamlet, a play, and therefore implies a transition from stage representation to novelization, “from the showing mode to the telling mode” (Bandín and González). Ian McEwan did not renounce his visual ambitions when writing Nutshell (Guignery) but instead “the book […] is clearly generated by the technical challenges implicit in the opening sentence, rather than a story that McEwan urgently needs to tell” (Tayler). Therefore, the following questions must be asked about Nutshell: how is such visuality, or visibility, made possible in a novel whose narrator is blind? Exactly what tricks do the narrator and writer rely on to transform blindness into images? And what is the reader really given to look at? This article argues that Nutshell fails to transition “from the showing mode to the telling mode”. It attempts instead to picture blindness by relying on what can be called echographic writing-the translation of sounds into images-as well as incomplete staging of the foetus’s condition. These inappropriate mechanisms threaten the integrity of the novel, eventually leaving narrator, reader and writer in the dark.

Dates et versions

hal-03950063 , version 1 (21-01-2023)

Identifiants

Citer

Maxence Gouleau. “The rest is silence”: Picturing the Unseen in Nutshell. Polysèmes, 2022, 27, ⟨10.4000/polysemes.10060⟩. ⟨hal-03950063⟩
16 Consultations
0 Téléchargements

Altmetric

Partager

Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More