Nitrene transfer reactions have emerged as one of the most powerful and versatile ways to insert an amine function to various kinds of hydrocarbon substrates. However, the mechanisms of nitrene generation have not been studied in depth albeit their formation is taken for granted in most cases without definitive evidence of their occurrence. In the present work, we compare the generation of tosylimido iron species and NTs transfer from Fe-II and Fe-III precursors where the metal is embedded in a tetracarbene macrocycle. Catalytic nitrene transfer to reference substrates (thioanisole, styrene, ethylbenzene and cyclohexane) revealed that the same active species was at play, irrespective of the ferrous versus ferric nature of the precursor. Through combination of spectroscopic (UV-visible, Mossbauer), ESI-MS and DFT studies, an Fe-IV tosylimido species was identified as the catalytically active species and was characterized spectroscopically and computationally. Whereas its formation from the Fe-II precursor was expected by a two-electron oxidative addition, its formation from an Fe-III precursor was unprecedented. Thanks to a combination of spectroscopic (UV-visible, EPR, Hyscore and Mossbauer), ESI-MS and DFT studies, we found that, when starting from the Fe-III precursor, an Fe-III tosyliodinane adduct was formed and decomposed into an Fe-V tosylimido species which generated the catalytically active Fe-IV tosylimide through a comproportionation process with the Fe-III precursor.