Energy Production Plant Noise Unpleasantness Reduction: The Benefits of a Sound Design Approach
Résumé
Electric power plant noise results from a combination of many sound sources whose spectral composition varies
according to the equipment: broadband noises mainly related to cooling towers, tonal emergence noises from e.g.
transformers and other noises whose spectrum is located in the middle frequencies. In order to study the impact
of industrial noise from a ‘sound design’ point of view, two experiments were conducted. In the first, sixteen
stimuli were created by combining cooling tower noise, transformer noise and another source of industrial noise,
mixed with two types of background noise (‘nature’ and ‘road traffic’). Via a computer interface, thirty-two
people played on the composition of industrial stimuli while keeping the overall level constant at 40 dB(A) to
design ‘optimized’ stimuli. Thus, three types of strategies were shared by the participants. The most commonly
used strategy involved masking the tonal emergence by broadband noise from the cooling tower. For this group
of participants, the increased pleasantness of listening to this optimized stimulus is equivalent to a sound level
reduction in the original sound of approximately 3 dB(A). A second group modifies the original sound very little
and therefore the increase in pleasantness is almost nil. Finally, only three people, statistically too small for us
to deduce any real optimization strategy, tend to reduce broadband noise. In a second experiment, thirty-two new
people who had not participated in the optimization phase compared the pleasantness of signals whose broadband
component noise level was increased compared to the two others with signals whose three sources were at the
same sound level. This second experiment made it possible to find a majority group of listeners who largely
prefer the sounds where the broadband component predominates. For a second group of people, the change in
the spectral balance, in other words the ‘sound design’, has little effect on the perceived pleasantness, and this is
mainly dictated by the overall sound level. Finally, for a single person, increasing the proportion of noise from
the cooling towers seems to be detrimental to pleasantness.