Once upon Multivariate Analyses: When They Tell Several Stories about Biological Evolution - Archive ouverte HAL Access content directly
Journal Articles PLoS ONE Year : 2015

Once upon Multivariate Analyses: When They Tell Several Stories about Biological Evolution


Geometric morphometrics aims to characterize of the geometry of complex traits. It is therefore by essence multivariate. The most popular methods to investigate patterns of differentiation in this context are (1) the Principal Component Analysis (PCA), which is an eigenvalue decomposition of the total variance-covariance matrix among all specimens; (2) the Canonical Variate Analysis (CVA, a.k.a. linear discriminant analysis (LDA) for more than two groups), which aims at separating the groups by maximizing the between-group to withingroup variance ratio; (3) the between-group PCA (bgPCA) which investigates patterns of between-group variation, without standardizing by the within-group variance. Standardizing within-group variance, as performed in the CVA, distorts the relationships among groups, an effect that is particularly strong if the variance is similarly oriented in a comparable way in all groups. Such shared direction of main morphological variance may occur and have a biological meaning, for instance corresponding to the most frequent standing genetic variation in a population. Here we undertake a case study of the evolution of house mouse molar shape across various islands, based on the real dataset and simulations. We investigated how patterns of main variance influence the depiction of among-group differentiation according to the interpretation of the PCA, bgPCA and CVA. Without arguing about a method performing 'better' than another, it rather emerges that working on the total or between-group variance (PCA and bgPCA) will tend to put the focus on the role of direction of main variance as line of least resistance to evolution. Standardizing by the within-group variance (CVA), by dampening the expression of this line of least resistance, has the potential to reveal other relevant patterns of differentiation that may otherwise be blurred.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
Once upon Multivariate Analyses When They Tell Several Stories about Biological Evolution.PDF (1.94 Mo) Télécharger le fichier
Origin : Publisher files allowed on an open archive

Dates and versions

hal-02316829 , version 1 (25-11-2020)





Sabrina Renaud, Anne-Béatrice Dufour, Emilie A Hardouin, Ronan Ledevin, Jean-Christophe Auffray. Once upon Multivariate Analyses: When They Tell Several Stories about Biological Evolution. PLoS ONE, 2015, 10 (7), pp.e0132801. ⟨10.1371/journal.pone.0132801⟩. ⟨hal-02316829⟩
95 View
28 Download



Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More