Cost-benefit analysis of first-and second-generation biofuels based on an economic valuation of life-cycle impacts - Archive ouverte HAL Accéder directement au contenu
Communication Dans Un Congrès Année : 2016

Cost-benefit analysis of first-and second-generation biofuels based on an economic valuation of life-cycle impacts

Stephan Marette
Vincent Martinet

Résumé

In the face of the current push for liquid biofuels worldwide, the design of policies compatible with sustainable development requires a careful and comprehensive analysis of their respective benefits and drawbacks. The environmental impacts of biofuels are usually quantified with life-cycle assessment (LCA), which provides indicators for a suitable range of impacts but leaves their prioritization up to decision-makers. Cost-benefit analysis (CBA) may be used to aggregate these impacts through an economic valuation of positive and negative effects on the environment. Here, we propose a simplified and ad hoc framework to combine LCA with CBA based on different valuations found in the literature, and apply it to a case-study comparing first-and second-generation biofuels in the Picardy region (northern France). The results were compared to 2 other methods already used to monetize externalities: the Eco-Cost method, and a method developed as part of the European Nitrogen Assessment. In terms of LCA, 2G bioethanol from miscanthus emitted 30 to 90% less pollutants than its 1G counterpart from sugar-beet, due to its lower requirements in agricultural inputs. This was directly reflected in the ad hoc CBA results, with a 3 to 6-fold decrease between the external costs of sugar-beet and miscanthus ethanol for the 4 impact categories monetized. There was a large variation between the valuation methods, which varied within an order of magnitude. For instance, the eutrophication costs associated with sugar-beet ethanol varied from 4 10-4to 4 10-3€/MJ of biofuel. Compared to fossil fuels, miscanthus-based ethanol incurred an overall net positive externality of 0.1€/MJ of biofuel, which is on a par with the tax exemption level put in place by the French government for 2ndgeneration biofuels.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
24th_EUBCE_Gabrielle_et_al.pdf (143.68 Ko) Télécharger le fichier
Origine Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s)

Dates et versions

hal-02282258 , version 1 (23-02-2022)

Identifiants

Citer

Benoit Gabrielle, Yuanzao Zhu, Stephan Marette, Vincent Martinet. Cost-benefit analysis of first-and second-generation biofuels based on an economic valuation of life-cycle impacts. European Biomass Conference and Exhibition Proceedings (2016) 2016(24thEUBCE), ETA-Florence Renewable Energies., Jun 2016, Amsterdam, Netherlands. ⟨10.5071/24thEUBCE2016-4BO.13.5⟩. ⟨hal-02282258⟩
105 Consultations
341 Téléchargements

Altmetric

Partager

Gmail Mastodon Facebook X LinkedIn More