Comments on "Series for Collision Probability in Short-Encounter Model" - Archive ouverte HAL Access content directly
Journal Articles Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics Year : 2020

Comments on "Series for Collision Probability in Short-Encounter Model"

Abstract

An analytic solution based on a series expansion of the collision probability of two spheres under the assumption of short-term encounters has recently been proposed in \cite{Garcia-PelayoJGCD2016}. Relying on the analycity of the Gaussian distribution of the relative positions and its Taylor expansion, this approach yields a series expansion for the classical 2D formulation of the collision probability, where the terms are obtained as a product of Hermite polynomials. Unfortunately, this work cannot be considered as a new contribution to the field since the method itself is nothing but a crude variety of the method published shortly before in \cite{serraJGCD2016} (see also the early conference version \cite{Serra2014}) and referenced in \cite{Garcia-PelayoJGCD2016}. Indeed, this note shows that the series expansion formulation of the probability collision given in \cite{Garcia-PelayoJGCD2016} is exactly the one exposed in \cite{serraJGCD2016} without a preconditionner and therefore suffers from numerical issues clearly identified in this article and due to the so-called cancellation phenomenon. Classic and real-case numerical examples further demonstrate that the results of \cite{Garcia-PelayoJGCD2016} are of limited interest.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
Comment_Pelayo_Ayuso.pdf (196.77 Ko) Télécharger le fichier
Origin : Files produced by the author(s)
Loading...

Dates and versions

hal-02123054 , version 1 (07-05-2019)

Identifiers

Cite

Denis Arzelier, Florent Bréhard, Mioara Joldes. Comments on "Series for Collision Probability in Short-Encounter Model". Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics, 2020, 43 (5), ⟨10.2514/1.G004560⟩. ⟨hal-02123054⟩
94 View
145 Download

Altmetric

Share

Gmail Facebook Twitter LinkedIn More