Comparison of the efficacy of spectral pre-treatments for wheat and weed discrimination in outdoor conditions
Comparaison de l'efficacité de divers pré-traitement de spectres pour la discrimination du blé et des mauvaises herbes au champ
Résumé
The optimal processing of spectral data often requires specific pre-treatments. In the context of spectral discrimination, results can be greatly improved using the relevant pre-treatment. Most importantly, the pre-treatment must
be suited to the nuisance variability that has to be removed. This study focuses on discrimination of weed and wheat using spectra acquired in outdoor conditions with uncontrolled lighting and leaf orientations. Both vegetation
spectra are highly similar, and due to the context of acquisition, a lot of spectral variability is present. This nuisance variability is modeled using an additive, multiplicative and noise term, each of which aspects the measured spectra. Several pre-treatments were therefore evaluated according to their potential to deal with this variability and their eects were described in the feature space. Finally, results obtained with these pre-treatments combined with two discrimination methods (PLS-LDA and Gaussian SVM) are compared and discussed. Results showed that, thanks to their ability to remove
nuisance variability, most pre-treatments are eective in terms of classification accuracy. Gaussian SVM classification results are less in uenced by pre-treatments than those of PLS-LDA, since the former compensates the
pre-treatment effect by using a different non-linear kernel. For this data-set, the best discrimination result was obtained using the combination logarithm and PLS-LDA. Logarithm actually transforms the multiplicative effect into and additive one, which is then eectively dealt with by PLS-LDA.
Origine | Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s) |
---|
Loading...