Open Review of "The average conformation tensor of interatomic bonds as an alternative state variable to the strain tensor: definition and first application—the case of nanoelasticity"
Résumé
The very first version of this article was refused for publication by the Associate Editor (AE) which was chosen by the Author. The Author then substantially clarified his paper and submitted it again by choosing another AE, who found a suitable expert for reviewing it. The Reviewer asked for major revision, however, the second AE became no longer available for processing the paper. Then the first AE accepted to continue the work and asked the Author to carry out the major modifications. The Author complied very well to the criticisms and reworked his manuscript substantially. Then the Reviewer accepted the new version with further minor modifications for the final version, which was verified by the AE. In conclusion, the acceptance was based on one substantial external review, and on the evaluation by two AEs of the journal.
Domaines
Mécanique [physics]
Origine : Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s)
licence : CC BY - Paternité
licence : CC BY - Paternité