Integrating tumor kinetics and circulating cell-free DNA markers through mechanistic modeling for early prediction of immunotherapy response
Résumé
Many cancer patients undergoing immune-checkpoint inhibition (ICI) experience early progression
(EP), defined as progression at the first imaging evaluation. Circulating cell-free DNA (cfDNA)
fragmentation profiles, especially fragment size distribution, offer a promising non-invasive method for
assessing treatment response independently of a specific molecular target, cancer type, and treatment.
However, only few computational modeling studies investigated the underlying biological mechanisms
of cfDNA dynamics during treatment monitoring.
The SChISM (Size CfDNA Immunotherapies Signature Monitoring) clinical study focuses on
monitoring the plasmatic cfDNA size profile of the fragmentome in 139 advanced pan-cancer patients
undergoing ICI treatment. The aim is to early manage therapeutic strategy before ICI-related
progression or toxicity occurs.
We performed statistical and survival biomarker analysis aimed to predict EP and progression-free
survival (PFS) using pre-treatment data. Plasmatic fragmentome-derived metrics, including
concentration, size distribution of first and second peaks, and specific size ranges (p = 11 variables),
were evaluated alongside standard clinical markers such as ECOG performance status, age, and
pathology. The relative quantity of fragments over 1650 bp exhibited the highest discriminatory power
for EP (median area under ROC curve on the test set = 0.7, 95% CI: 0.59-0.80). A lower relative quantity
of these long fragments correlated with EP and shorter PFS in both the univariate and multivariate
settings.
Following the development of empirical models capturing inter- and intra-patient variability in cfDNA
metrics, a system of differential equations was constructed to individually describe cfDNA kinetics.
Subsequently, a mechanistic model integrating cfDNA kinetics with longitudinal biological markers
and tumor size imaging was developed to elucidate and comprehend the temporal dynamics of cfDNA
quantitative profiles over time. Using population data, the model was calibrated within the nonlinear
mixed effects statistical framework. Future perspective aim to employ machine learning models to
predict EP, PFS or overall survival by integrating dynamic parameters with baseline variables.