Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is an approved cancer treatment modality. Despite its high efficiency, PDT is limited in terms of specificity and by the poor solubility of the rather lipophilic photosensitizers (PSs). In order to alleviate these limitations, PSs can be conjugated to oligonucleotides. However, most conjugation methods often involve complex organic synthesis and result in the appendage of single modifications at the 3’/5’ termini of oligonucleotides. Here, we have investigated the possibility of bioconjugating a range of known PSs by polymerase-mediated synthesis. We have prepared a range of modified nucleoside triphosphates by different conjugation methods and investigated the substrate tolerance of these nucleotides for template-dependent and -independent DNA polymerases. This method represents a mild and versatile approach for the conjugation of single or multiple PSs onto oligonucleotides and can be useful to further improve the efficiency of the PDT treatment.