The Surprise Deception Paradox - Archive ouverte HAL
Pré-Publication, Document De Travail Année : 2024

The Surprise Deception Paradox

Benjamin Icard
  • Fonction : Auteur
  • PersonId : 1262334

Résumé

This article tackles an epistemic puzzle formulated by R. Smullyan that we call the ‘Surprise Deception Paradox'. On the morning of April 1st 1925, his brother announced that he would deceive him during the day, but apparently nothing happened. Since R. Smullyan waited all day to be deceived by some action, he was actually deceived, but by the lack of an action, that is to say by omission. Afterwards, Smullyan felt immediately puzzled: because he expected to be deceived, he was not deceived; but since he was not deceived the way he expected, he was actually deceived. We use dynamic belief revision logic to look more clearly into this puzzle. We argue that Smullyan's reasoning is not a self-referential paradox but shares common features with the more famous Surprise Examination Paradox. In Smullyan's riddle, we show that a misleading default mechanism makes R. Smullyan surprised by the deception he has been preyed to. We also use this solution to discuss whether such defaults, compared to other forms of truth-telling deception, may qualify as lies or not.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
The_Surprise_Deception_Paradox_version4.pdf (495.47 Ko) Télécharger le fichier
Origine Fichiers produits par l'(les) auteur(s)
Licence

Dates et versions

hal-04647404 , version 1 (14-07-2024)
hal-04647404 , version 2 (15-07-2024)
hal-04647404 , version 3 (07-08-2024)
hal-04647404 , version 4 (13-08-2024)

Licence

Identifiants

  • HAL Id : hal-04647404 , version 4

Citer

Benjamin Icard. The Surprise Deception Paradox. 2024. ⟨hal-04647404v4⟩
167 Consultations
71 Téléchargements

Partager

More