Constructing water governability in Ceará: advances and challenges after four decades of reforms
A construção da governabilidade da água no Ceará: avanços e desafios após quatro décadas de reformas
Résumé
The management of water resources in the Brazilian state of Ceará has been widely praised for its governance,
commonly regarded as remarkably participatory and integrated. However, this model, whose essential
contours were designed between 1987 and 1993, also included a governability project. The democratization
of governance was conceived as a tool to better know about, control, and direct the uses of water by state
agencies, at different scales. After three decades of implementation, what has this project of governability
through democratic means achieved? In this paper, we argue that governance arrangements were, on the one
hand, fundamental to furthering water governability at the “meso” level of watersheds; but, on the other hand,
that they were much less conducive to strengthening governability at the more “micro”, local level. We attribute
these ambivalent effects to two mechanisms. First, the implementation of the model raised many issues related
to the institutional organization of watersheds, which consequently monopolized stakeholders’ attention, to
the detriment of the challenges that emerged at the local level. Second, governance arrangements eventually
confined municipalities to a subordinate role, even though local governments remain indispensable actors to
advance local governability. Thus, we foreground two unexpected effects of governance on governability: the
monopolization of attention and the marginalization of an influential actor. Insofar as these effects may well
end up destabilizing the governance architecture itself, we conceptualize them as ‘negative’ policy feedback,
which the paper thus contributes to identify. In conclusion, we argue that only more inclusive and deliberative
forms of governance at the local level may strenghten the local governability of water resources, thereby
opening a new chapter for the “Ceará model”.
Fichier principal
MAYAUX&al. Constructing water governability in Ceará.pdf (1.04 Mo)
Télécharger le fichier
Origine | Fichiers éditeurs autorisés sur une archive ouverte |
---|