<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:hal="http://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/" xmlns:gml="http://www.opengis.net/gml/3.3/" xmlns:gmlce="http://www.opengis.net/gml/3.3/ce" version="1.1" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0 http://api.archives-ouvertes.fr/documents/aofr-sword.xsd">
  <teiHeader>
    <fileDesc>
      <titleStmt>
        <title>HAL TEI export of hal-04147451</title>
      </titleStmt>
      <publicationStmt>
        <distributor>CCSD</distributor>
        <availability status="restricted">
          <licence target="https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/">CC0 1.0 - Universal</licence>
        </availability>
        <date when="2026-05-14T10:25:28+02:00"/>
      </publicationStmt>
      <sourceDesc>
        <p part="N">HAL API Platform</p>
      </sourceDesc>
    </fileDesc>
  </teiHeader>
  <text>
    <body>
      <listBibl>
        <biblFull>
          <titleStmt>
            <title xml:lang="en">To Be or Not to Be: The Ontological Predicament of State Creation in International Law</title>
            <author role="aut">
              <persName>
                <forename type="first">Janis</forename>
                <surname>Grzybowski</surname>
              </persName>
              <email type="md5">dea508f3975208f668a7284e8a1cb9d2</email>
              <email type="domain">univ-catholille.fr</email>
              <idno type="idhal" notation="numeric">827658</idno>
              <idno type="halauthorid" notation="string">2512521-827658</idno>
              <idno type="ORCID">https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5713-9084</idno>
              <affiliation ref="#struct-527713"/>
            </author>
            <editor role="depositor">
              <persName>
                <forename>Janis</forename>
                <surname>Grzybowski</surname>
              </persName>
              <email type="md5">dea02cb7c688cf5090c9bae1937c2521</email>
              <email type="domain">graduateinstitute.ch</email>
            </editor>
          </titleStmt>
          <editionStmt>
            <edition n="v1" type="current">
              <date type="whenSubmitted">2023-07-06 15:51:35</date>
              <date type="whenModified">2023-08-30 04:40:40</date>
              <date type="whenReleased">2023-07-06 15:51:35</date>
              <date type="whenProduced">2017</date>
              <ref type="externalLink" target="https://academic.oup.com/ejil/article-pdf/28/2/409/18220147/chx031.pdf"/>
            </edition>
            <respStmt>
              <resp>contributor</resp>
              <name key="1436901">
                <persName>
                  <forename>Janis</forename>
                  <surname>Grzybowski</surname>
                </persName>
                <email type="md5">dea02cb7c688cf5090c9bae1937c2521</email>
                <email type="domain">graduateinstitute.ch</email>
              </name>
            </respStmt>
          </editionStmt>
          <publicationStmt>
            <distributor>CCSD</distributor>
            <idno type="halId">hal-04147451</idno>
            <idno type="halUri">https://hal.science/hal-04147451</idno>
            <idno type="halBibtex">grzybowski:hal-04147451</idno>
            <idno type="halRefHtml">&lt;i&gt;European Journal of International Law&lt;/i&gt;, 2017, 28 (2), pp.409-432. &lt;a target="_blank" href="https://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ejil/chx031"&gt;&amp;#x27E8;10.1093/ejil/chx031&amp;#x27E9;&lt;/a&gt;</idno>
            <idno type="halRef">European Journal of International Law, 2017, 28 (2), pp.409-432. &amp;#x27E8;10.1093/ejil/chx031&amp;#x27E9;</idno>
            <availability status="restricted"/>
          </publicationStmt>
          <seriesStmt>
            <idno type="stamp" n="SHS">Sciences de l'Homme et de la Société</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="ESPOL" corresp="SHS">European School of Political and Social Sciences / École Européenne de Sciences Politiques et Sociales</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="UNIV-CATHOLILLE">Université catholique de Lille</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="ICL" corresp="UNIV-CATHOLILLE">Institut Catholique de Lille</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="ESPOL_ICL" corresp="UNIV-CATHOLILLE">ESPOL - École Européenne de Sciences Politiques et Sociales</idno>
          </seriesStmt>
          <notesStmt>
            <note type="audience" n="2">International</note>
            <note type="popular" n="0">No</note>
            <note type="peer" n="1">Yes</note>
          </notesStmt>
          <sourceDesc>
            <biblStruct>
              <analytic>
                <title xml:lang="en">To Be or Not to Be: The Ontological Predicament of State Creation in International Law</title>
                <author role="aut">
                  <persName>
                    <forename type="first">Janis</forename>
                    <surname>Grzybowski</surname>
                  </persName>
                  <email type="md5">dea508f3975208f668a7284e8a1cb9d2</email>
                  <email type="domain">univ-catholille.fr</email>
                  <idno type="idhal" notation="numeric">827658</idno>
                  <idno type="halauthorid" notation="string">2512521-827658</idno>
                  <idno type="ORCID">https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5713-9084</idno>
                  <affiliation ref="#struct-527713"/>
                </author>
              </analytic>
              <monogr>
                <idno type="halJournalId" status="VALID">4728</idno>
                <idno type="issn">0938-5428</idno>
                <idno type="eissn">1464-3596</idno>
                <title level="j">European Journal of International Law</title>
                <imprint>
                  <publisher>Oxford University Press (OUP)</publisher>
                  <biblScope unit="volume">28</biblScope>
                  <biblScope unit="issue">2</biblScope>
                  <biblScope unit="pp">409–432</biblScope>
                  <date type="datePub">2017</date>
                </imprint>
              </monogr>
              <idno type="doi">10.1093/ejil/chx031</idno>
            </biblStruct>
          </sourceDesc>
          <profileDesc>
            <langUsage>
              <language ident="en">English</language>
            </langUsage>
            <textClass>
              <classCode scheme="halDomain" n="shs">Humanities and Social Sciences</classCode>
              <classCode scheme="halTypology" n="ART">Journal articles</classCode>
              <classCode scheme="halOldTypology" n="ART">Journal articles</classCode>
              <classCode scheme="halTreeTypology" n="ART">Journal articles</classCode>
            </textClass>
            <abstract xml:lang="en">
              <p>International law is classically based on a system of states whose members it attempts to identify by virtue of their effectiveness, their recognition by other states, and their creation in accordance with the rules of international law. In this article, I illustrate the indeterminacy of these three dimensions and argue that assessments of individual state creations are instead necessarily based on blunt, but silent, ontological commitments to any potential state’s full presence or absence. While the ‘great debate’ between declaratory and constitutive doctrines of recognition has emphasized, but not finally determined, the ontology of the state, attempts to find compromises between material effectiveness and constitutive recognition as well as the turn towards the proper legal regulation of state creation have only bracketed and invisibilized its decisive role. The deconstruction of state identifications reveals an essentially empty state ontology that confronts scholars and practitioners with the predicament of having to ultimately presuppose any particular state’s existence or its absence. This not only allows for reflecting on the stakes of individual assessments but also shows how all state identifications inevitably reproduce the hegemonic image of an exclusive and neatly delineated state system that brings its unruly fringes under control time and again.</p>
            </abstract>
          </profileDesc>
        </biblFull>
      </listBibl>
    </body>
    <back>
      <listOrg type="structures">
        <org type="laboratory" xml:id="struct-527713" status="VALID">
          <orgName>European School of Political and Social Sciences / École Européenne de Sciences Politiques et Sociales</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">ESPOL</orgName>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <addrLine>60 boulevard VaubanCS 4010959016 Lille Cedex</addrLine>
              <country key="FR"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">http://espol-lille.eu/</ref>
          </desc>
          <listRelation>
            <relation active="#struct-355271" type="direct"/>
            <relation active="#struct-300877" type="indirect"/>
          </listRelation>
        </org>
        <org type="institution" xml:id="struct-355271" status="VALID">
          <orgName>Institut Catholique de Lille</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">ICL</orgName>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <addrLine>60, boulevard Vauban / 59800 LILLE</addrLine>
              <country key="FR"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">http://www.univ-catholille.fr/</ref>
          </desc>
          <listRelation>
            <relation active="#struct-300877" type="direct"/>
          </listRelation>
        </org>
        <org type="regroupinstitution" xml:id="struct-300877" status="VALID">
          <idno type="IdRef">026582481</idno>
          <idno type="ROR">https://ror.org/025s1b152</idno>
          <orgName>Université catholique de Lille</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">UCL</orgName>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <addrLine>60 boulevard Vauban - 59800 Lille</addrLine>
              <country key="FR"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">http://www.univ-catholille.fr/</ref>
          </desc>
        </org>
      </listOrg>
    </back>
  </text>
</TEI>