Objective: To test the hypothesis that temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) patients with subjective initial memory complaints (not confirmed by an objective standard assessment) and various phenotypes also show objective very long-term memory deficit with accelerated long-term forgetting, we tested TLE patients with two surprise memory tests after 3 weeks: (1) the standard Free and Cued Selective Reminding Test (FCSRT), and (2) Epireal, a new test specifically designed to capture more ecological aspects of autobiographical memory. Methods: 47 TLE patients (12 hippocampal sclerosis, 12 amygdala enlargement, 11 extensive lesions, 12 normal MRI) who complained about their memory, but for whom the standard neuropsychological assessment did not reveal any memory impairment after a standard delay of 20 min, underwent two surprise memory tests after three weeks. They were compared to 35 healthy control subjects. Results: After 3 weeks, FCSRT and Epireal recall scores were significantly lower in patients than in controls (p<0.001). There was no significant correlation between FCSRT and Epireal scores (p=0.99). Seventy-six percent of TLE patients had objective impairment on at least one of these very long-term memory tests, regardless of the existence and type of lesion or response to antiseizure medication. Easily applicable, Epireal had a higher effect size, detected deficits in 28 % more patients, and is a useful addition to the standard workup. Conclusion: Assessing long-term memory should be broadened to a wide spectrum of TLE patients with a memory complaint, regardless of the epileptic syndrome, and associated with a lesion or not. This could lead to rethinking TLE nosology associated with memory.