Impact of advance directives on the variability between intensivists in the decisions to forgo life-sustaining treatment - Archive ouverte HAL Accéder directement au contenu
Article Dans Une Revue Critical Care Année : 2020

Impact of advance directives on the variability between intensivists in the decisions to forgo life-sustaining treatment

Virginie Guastella
Anne Medard
  • Fonction : Auteur
Jean-Philippe Rigaud
  • Fonction : Auteur
  • PersonId : 891933
  • IdRef : 085645052
Pierre Asfar
Jean Dellamonica

Résumé

Background: There is wide variability between intensivists in the decisions to forgo life-sustaining treatment (DFLST). Advance directives (ADs) allow patients to communicate their end-of-life wishes to physicians. We assessed whether ADs reduced variability in DFLSTs between intensivists.Methods: We conducted a multicenter, prospective, simulation study. Eight patients expressed their wishes in ADs after being informed about DFLSTs by an intensivist-investigator. The participating intensivists answered ten questions about the DFLSTs of each patient in two scenarios, referring to patients' characteristics without ADs (round 1) and then with (round 2). DFLST score ranged from 0 (no-DFLST) to 10 (DFLST for all questions). The main outcome was variability in DFLSTs between intensivists, expressed as relative standard deviation (RSD).Results: A total of 19,680 decisions made by 123 intensivists from 27 ICUs were analyzed. The DFLST score was higher with ADs than without (6.02 95% CI [5.85; 6.19] vs 4.92 95% CI [4.75; 5.10], p < 0.001). High inter-intensivist variability did not change with ADs (RSD: 0.56 (round 1) vs 0.46 (round 2), p = 0.84). Inter-intensivist agreement on DFLSTs was weak with ADs (intra-class correlation coefficient: 0.28). No factor associated with DFLSTs was identified. A qualitative analysis of ADs showed focus on end-of-life wills, unwanted things and fear of pain.Conclusions: ADs increased the DFLST rate but did not reduce variability between the intensivists. In the decision-making process using ADs, the intensivist's decision took priority. Further research is needed to improve the matching of the physicians' decision with the patient's wishes.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
s13054-020-03402-7.pdf (1.13 Mo) Télécharger le fichier
Origine : Fichiers éditeurs autorisés sur une archive ouverte

Dates et versions

hal-03040555 , version 1 (02-06-2021)

Licence

Paternité

Identifiants

Citer

Margot Smirdec, Mercé Jourdain, Virginie Guastella, Céline Lambert, Jean-Christophe Richard, et al.. Impact of advance directives on the variability between intensivists in the decisions to forgo life-sustaining treatment. Critical Care, 2020, 24 (1), pp.672. ⟨10.1186/s13054-020-03402-7⟩. ⟨hal-03040555⟩
234 Consultations
68 Téléchargements

Altmetric

Partager

Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More