Crop pests and predators exhibit inconsistent responses to surrounding landscape composition - Archive ouverte HAL Access content directly
Journal Articles Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America Year : 2018

Crop pests and predators exhibit inconsistent responses to surrounding landscape composition

Daniel S. Karp , Rebecca Chaplin-Kramer , Timothy D. Meehan , Emily A. Martin , Fabrice Declerck , Heather Grab , Claudio Gratton , Lauren Hunt , Ashley E. Larsen , Alejandra Martínez-Salinas , Megan E. O’rourke , Adrien Rusch , Katja Poveda , Mattias Jonsson , Jay A. Rosenheim , Nancy A. Schellhorn , Teja Tscharntke , Stephen D. Wratten , Wei Zhang , Aaron L. Iverson , Lynn S. Adler , Matthias Albrecht , Audrey Alignier , Gina M. Angelella , Muhammad Zubair Anjum , Jacques Avelino , Péter Batáry , Johannes M. Baveco , Felix J. J. A. Bianchi , Klaus Birkhofer , Eric W. Bohnenblust , Riccardo Bommarco , Michael J. Brewer , Berta Caballero-López , Yves Carrière , Luísa G. Carvalheiro , Luis Cayuela , Mary Centrella , Dominic Charles Henri , Ariane Chabert (1) , Alejandro C. Costamagna , Aldo de La Mora , Joop de Kraker , Nicolas Desneux , Eva Diehl , Tim Diekötter , Carsten F. Dormann , James O. Eckberg , Martin H. Entling , Daniela Fiedler , Pierre Franck , F. J. Frank van Veen , Thomas Frank , Vesna Gagic , Michael P. D. Garratt , Awraris Getachew , David J. Gonthier , Peter B. Goodell , Ignazio Graziosi , Russell L. Groves , Geoff M. Gurr , Zachary Hajian-Forooshani , George E. Heimpel , John D. Herrmann , Anders S. Huseth , Diego J. Inclán , Adam J. Ingrao , Phirun Iv , Katja Jacot , Gregg A. Johnson , Laura Jones , Marina Kaiser , Joe M. Kaser , Tamar Keasar , Tania N. Kim , Miriam Kishinevsky , Douglas A. Landis , Blas Lavandero , Claire Lavigne , Anne Le Ralec (2) , Debissa Lemessa , Deborah K. Letourneau , Heidi Liere , Yanhui Lu , Yael Lubin , Tim Luttermoser , Bea Maas , Kevi Mace , Filipe Madeira , Viktoria Mader , Anne Marie Cortesero (2) , Lorenzo Marini , Eliana Martinez , Holly M. Martinson , Philippe Menozzi , Matthew G. E. Mitchell , Tadashi Miyashita , Gonzalo A. R. Molina , Marco A. Molina-Montenegro , Matthew E. O’neal , Itai Opatovsky , Sebaastian Ortiz-Martinez , Michael Nash , Annie Ouin (1) , Damie Pak , Daniel Paredes , Soroush Parsa , Hazel Parry , Ricardo Perez-Alvarez , David J. Perović , Julie A. Peterson , Sandrine Petit , Stacy M. Philpott , Manuel Plantegenest (2) , Milan Plećaš , Therese Pluess , Xavier Pons , Simon G. Potts , Richard F. Pywell , David W. Ragsdale , Tatyana A. Rand , Lucie Raymond (2) , Benoît Ricci , Chris Sargent , Jean-Pierre Sarthou (1) , Julia Saulais (2) , Jessica Schäckermann , Nick P. Schmidt , Gudrun Schneider , Christof Schüepp , Frances S. Sivakoff , Henrik G. Smith , Kaitlin Stack Whitney , Sonja Stutz , Zsofia Szendrei , Mayura B. Takada , Hisatomo Taki , Giovanni Tamburini , Linda J. Thomson , Yann Tricault , Noelline Tsafack , Matthias Tschumi , Muriel Valantin-Morison , Mai van Trinh , Wopke van Der Werf , Kerri T. Vierling , Ben P. Werling , Jennifer B. Wickens , Victoria J. Wickens , Ben A. Woodcock , Kris Wyckhuys , Haijun Xiao , Mika Yasuda , Akira Yoshioka , Yi Zou
Daniel S. Karp
  • Function : Correspondent author
Rebecca Chaplin-Kramer
  • Function : Author
Timothy D. Meehan
  • Function : Author
Emily A. Martin
  • Function : Author
Fabrice Declerck
  • Function : Author
Heather Grab
  • Function : Author
Claudio Gratton
  • Function : Author
Lauren Hunt
  • Function : Author
Ashley E. Larsen
  • Function : Author
Alejandra Martínez-Salinas
  • Function : Author
Megan E. O’rourke
  • Function : Author
Adrien Rusch
Katja Poveda
  • Function : Author
Mattias Jonsson
  • Function : Author
Jay A. Rosenheim
  • Function : Author
Nancy A. Schellhorn
  • Function : Author
Teja Tscharntke
  • Function : Author
Stephen D. Wratten
  • Function : Author
Wei Zhang
  • Function : Author
Aaron L. Iverson
  • Function : Author
Lynn S. Adler
  • Function : Author
Matthias Albrecht
  • Function : Author
Audrey Alignier
Gina M. Angelella
  • Function : Author
Muhammad Zubair Anjum
  • Function : Author
Jacques Avelino
Péter Batáry
Johannes M. Baveco
  • Function : Author
Felix J. J. A. Bianchi
  • Function : Author
Klaus Birkhofer
  • Function : Author
Eric W. Bohnenblust
  • Function : Author
Riccardo Bommarco
  • Function : Author
Michael J. Brewer
  • Function : Author
Berta Caballero-López
  • Function : Author
Yves Carrière
  • Function : Author
Luísa G. Carvalheiro
  • Function : Author
Luis Cayuela
  • Function : Author
Mary Centrella
  • Function : Author
Dominic Charles Henri
  • Function : Author
Alejandro C. Costamagna
  • Function : Author
Aldo de La Mora
  • Function : Author
Joop de Kraker
  • Function : Author
Nicolas Desneux
Eva Diehl
  • Function : Author
Tim Diekötter
  • Function : Author
Carsten F. Dormann
  • Function : Author
James O. Eckberg
  • Function : Author
Martin H. Entling
  • Function : Author
Daniela Fiedler
  • Function : Author
Pierre Franck
F. J. Frank van Veen
  • Function : Author
Thomas Frank
  • Function : Author
Vesna Gagic
  • Function : Author
Michael P. D. Garratt
  • Function : Author
Awraris Getachew
  • Function : Author
David J. Gonthier
  • Function : Author
Peter B. Goodell
  • Function : Author
Ignazio Graziosi
  • Function : Author
Russell L. Groves
  • Function : Author
Geoff M. Gurr
  • Function : Author
Zachary Hajian-Forooshani
  • Function : Author
George E. Heimpel
  • Function : Author
  • PersonId : 1047604
John D. Herrmann
  • Function : Author
Anders S. Huseth
  • Function : Author
Diego J. Inclán
  • Function : Author
Adam J. Ingrao
  • Function : Author
Phirun Iv
  • Function : Author
Katja Jacot
  • Function : Author
Gregg A. Johnson
  • Function : Author
Laura Jones
  • Function : Author
Marina Kaiser
  • Function : Author
Joe M. Kaser
  • Function : Author
Tamar Keasar
  • Function : Author
Tania N. Kim
  • Function : Author
Miriam Kishinevsky
  • Function : Author
Douglas A. Landis
  • Function : Author
Blas Lavandero
  • Function : Author
Claire Lavigne
Debissa Lemessa
  • Function : Author
Deborah K. Letourneau
  • Function : Author
Heidi Liere
  • Function : Author
Yanhui Lu
  • Function : Author
Yael Lubin
Tim Luttermoser
  • Function : Author
Bea Maas
  • Function : Author
Kevi Mace
  • Function : Author
Filipe Madeira
  • Function : Author
Viktoria Mader
  • Function : Author
Lorenzo Marini
  • Function : Author
Eliana Martinez
  • Function : Author
Holly M. Martinson
  • Function : Author
Philippe Menozzi
  • Function : Author
Matthew G. E. Mitchell
  • Function : Author
Tadashi Miyashita
  • Function : Author
Gonzalo A. R. Molina
  • Function : Author
Marco A. Molina-Montenegro
  • Function : Author
Matthew E. O’neal
  • Function : Author
Itai Opatovsky
  • Function : Author
Sebaastian Ortiz-Martinez
  • Function : Author
Michael Nash
  • Function : Author
Damie Pak
  • Function : Author
Daniel Paredes
  • Function : Author
Soroush Parsa
  • Function : Author
Hazel Parry
Ricardo Perez-Alvarez
  • Function : Author
David J. Perović
  • Function : Author
Julie A. Peterson
  • Function : Author
Sandrine Petit
Stacy M. Philpott
  • Function : Author
Milan Plećaš
  • Function : Author
Therese Pluess
  • Function : Author
Xavier Pons
  • Function : Author
  • PersonId : 1114525
Simon G. Potts
  • Function : Author
  • PersonId : 948075
Richard F. Pywell
  • Function : Author
David W. Ragsdale
  • Function : Author
Tatyana A. Rand
  • Function : Author
Benoît Ricci
Chris Sargent
  • Function : Author
Jessica Schäckermann
  • Function : Author
Nick P. Schmidt
  • Function : Author
Gudrun Schneider
  • Function : Author
Christof Schüepp
  • Function : Author
Frances S. Sivakoff
  • Function : Author
Henrik G. Smith
  • Function : Author
Kaitlin Stack Whitney
  • Function : Author
Sonja Stutz
  • Function : Author
Zsofia Szendrei
  • Function : Author
Mayura B. Takada
  • Function : Author
Hisatomo Taki
  • Function : Author
Giovanni Tamburini
  • Function : Author
Linda J. Thomson
  • Function : Author
Yann Tricault
Noelline Tsafack
Matthias Tschumi
  • Function : Author
Muriel Valantin-Morison
Mai van Trinh
  • Function : Author
Wopke van Der Werf
Kerri T. Vierling
  • Function : Author
Ben P. Werling
  • Function : Author
Jennifer B. Wickens
  • Function : Author
Victoria J. Wickens
  • Function : Author
Ben A. Woodcock
  • Function : Author
Kris Wyckhuys
  • Function : Author
Haijun Xiao
  • Function : Author
Mika Yasuda
  • Function : Author
Akira Yoshioka
  • Function : Author
Yi Zou

Abstract

The idea that noncrop habitat enhances pest control and represents a win-win opportunity to conserve biodiversity and bolster yields has emerged as an agroecological paradigm. However, while noncrop habitat in landscapes surrounding farms sometimes benefits pest predators, natural enemy responses remain heterogeneous across studies and effects on pests are inconclusive. The observed heterogeneity in species responses to noncrop habitat may be biological in origin or could result from variation in how habitat and biocontrol are measured. Here, we use a pest-control database encompassing 132 studies and 6,759 sites worldwide to model natural enemy and pest abundances, predation rates, and crop damage as a function of landscape composition. Our results showed that although landscape composition explained significant variation within studies, pest and enemy abundances, predation rates, crop damage, and yields each exhibited different responses across studies, sometimes increasing and sometimes decreasing in landscapes with more noncrop habitat but overall showing no consistent trend. Thus, models that used landscape-composition variables to predict pest-control dynamics demonstrated little potential to explain variation across studies, though prediction did improve when comparing studies with similar crop and landscape features. Overall, our work shows that surrounding noncrop habitat does not consistently improve pest management, meaning habitat conservation may bolster production in some systems and depress yields in others. Future efforts to develop tools that inform farmers when habitat conservation truly represents a win-win would benefit from increased understanding of how landscape effects are modulated by local farm management and the biology of pests and their enemies.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
Karp_20735.pdf (2.62 Mo) Télécharger le fichier
Origin : Files produced by the author(s)
Loading...

Dates and versions

hal-02134898 , version 1 (20-05-2019)

Licence

Attribution - NonCommercial - NoDerivatives

Identifiers

Cite

Daniel S. Karp, Rebecca Chaplin-Kramer, Timothy D. Meehan, Emily A. Martin, Fabrice Declerck, et al.. Crop pests and predators exhibit inconsistent responses to surrounding landscape composition. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2018, 115 (3), pp.1-8. ⟨10.1073/pnas.1800042115⟩. ⟨hal-02134898⟩
139 View
112 Download

Altmetric

Share

Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More