Hypoeutectic aluminum silicon alloys without and with additions of magnesium, copper, iron, and strontium have been cast in a mold, giving directional solidification from a chill. Detailed temperature measurements have been carried out. Solidification modeling based on front tracking of the microstructure growth fronts allowed identification of the time and temperature at which the dendrite tips and the first eutectic pass the thermocouples. The undercooling, growth rate, and thermal gradients at the dendritic and eutectic growth fronts were derived. The effect of varying thermal parameters and alloy compositions on the microstructure was investigated. Compared to the binary alloy, a coarser eutectic was observed in the alloys with magnesium, iron, and/or copper. The coarsening is explained as a result of the transition from a eutectic forming at one specific temperature, to a eutectic forming over a temperature range. The former is likely to grow as a plane front, whereas the latter is likely to form an interdendritic eutectic mushy zone.