Background and Aims Seeds buried in the soil detect burial depth through light and diurnally fluctuating temperatures (DFT) and in this way limit losses due to germination too deep in the soil. DFTs and germination also increase in vegetation gaps. However, dry open environments with high DFTs can also increase seedling mortality, creating conflicting selection pressures for reaction to DFTs. Since this questions the general function of DFT detection, we therefore tested if interspecific differences in DFT detection are related to mortality in different soil depths. Methods We buried seeds of ten annual plants including species pairs of increasing and decreasing germination in response to DFTs. Seeds were buried in 5, 10 and 25cm soil depth and exhumed after two different burial times. Seed viability was tested using germination in growth chambers and tetrazolium. We also measured DFTs at these depths using temperature data loggers. Results DFT detection was not related to differences in mortality at three burial depths. Three species showed a clear pattern of depth dependent mortality, however inconsistently related to DFT detection. Conclusions Depth detection mechanisms are more species-specific than expected. Hence, interspecific differences in seed mortalities are difficult to predict by DFT detection alone and alternative soil depth sensing mechanisms should be explored in future.