From Birthright Citizenship to Open Borders? Some Doubts - Archive ouverte HAL Accéder directement au contenu
Article Dans Une Revue Ethical perspectives / Catholic University of Leuven ; European Centre for Christian Ethics Année : 2014

From Birthright Citizenship to Open Borders? Some Doubts

Résumé

This paper argues that by overestimating the importance of citizenship rights, the ethics of immigration turns away from the more serious problem of closed borders. Precisely, this contribution is a threefold critique of Carens’ idea that "justice requires that democratic states grant citizenship at birth to the descendants of settled immigrants" (Carens, 2013: 20). Firstly, I argue that by making 'justice' dependent on states and their attributes (birthright citizenship), this idea strengthens methodological nationalism which views humanity as naturally divided into bounded nation-states. Secondly, I analyze its justification and argue that grounding (citizenship) rights on the existence of social connections is logically and morally problematic. Thirdly, I analyze its scope (granting rights to the descendants of the ‘settled’) and its method of implementation (granting citizenship rights automatically ‘at birth’). While from a less sedentarist perspective, no one can be considered ‘settled’ in advance, I will express some doubts that granting citizenship rights is always automatically a way to extend people’s rights. All in all, I argue that by its justification, scope and method of implementation, this idea moves us away from, rather than gets us closer to, an open-borders world.
Fichier principal
Vignette du fichier
Dumitru 2014 From birthright citizenship to open borders.pdf (154.17 Ko) Télécharger le fichier
Origine : Accord explicite pour ce dépôt
Loading...

Dates et versions

hal-01348305 , version 1 (01-09-2016)

Identifiants

  • HAL Id : hal-01348305 , version 1

Citer

Speranta Dumitru. From Birthright Citizenship to Open Borders? Some Doubts. Ethical perspectives / Catholic University of Leuven ; European Centre for Christian Ethics, 2014, 21 (4), pp.608-614. ⟨hal-01348305⟩
418 Consultations
130 Téléchargements

Partager

Gmail Facebook X LinkedIn More