<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns:hal="http://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/" xmlns:gml="http://www.opengis.net/gml/3.3/" xmlns:gmlce="http://www.opengis.net/gml/3.3/ce" version="1.1" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0 http://api.archives-ouvertes.fr/documents/aofr-sword.xsd">
  <teiHeader>
    <fileDesc>
      <titleStmt>
        <title>HAL TEI export of hal-00877050</title>
      </titleStmt>
      <publicationStmt>
        <distributor>CCSD</distributor>
        <availability status="restricted">
          <licence target="https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/">CC0 1.0 - Universal</licence>
        </availability>
        <date when="2026-05-08T17:55:34+02:00"/>
      </publicationStmt>
      <sourceDesc>
        <p part="N">HAL API Platform</p>
      </sourceDesc>
    </fileDesc>
  </teiHeader>
  <text>
    <body>
      <listBibl>
        <biblFull>
          <titleStmt>
            <title xml:lang="en">Should you believe in the Shanghai ranking? An MCDM view</title>
            <author role="aut">
              <persName>
                <forename type="first">Jean-Charles</forename>
                <surname>Billaut</surname>
              </persName>
              <email type="md5">a2a40e8ca3dc3579a37e3da8688c945e</email>
              <email type="domain">univ-tours.fr</email>
              <idno type="idhal" notation="string">jean-charles-billaut</idno>
              <idno type="idhal" notation="numeric">5922</idno>
              <idno type="halauthorid" notation="string">22560-5922</idno>
              <idno type="IDREF">https://www.idref.fr/059806257</idno>
              <idno type="ORCID">https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7938-1998</idno>
              <orgName ref="#struct-300298"/>
              <affiliation ref="#struct-204893"/>
            </author>
            <author role="aut">
              <persName>
                <forename type="first">Denis</forename>
                <surname>Bouyssou</surname>
              </persName>
              <email type="md5">fa1beb245eea400ffa684d8b0e1da034</email>
              <email type="domain">lamsade.dauphine.fr</email>
              <idno type="idhal" notation="string">denis-bouyssou</idno>
              <idno type="idhal" notation="numeric">182535</idno>
              <idno type="halauthorid" notation="string">47094-182535</idno>
              <idno type="ORCID">https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3487-8498</idno>
              <affiliation ref="#struct-989"/>
            </author>
            <author role="aut">
              <persName>
                <forename type="first">Philippe</forename>
                <surname>Vincke</surname>
              </persName>
              <idno type="halauthorid">103290-0</idno>
              <affiliation ref="#struct-94476"/>
            </author>
            <editor role="depositor">
              <persName>
                <forename>Eleni</forename>
                <surname>Palaiologou</surname>
              </persName>
              <email type="md5">93d31710abe44814729d73debe8e9f2e</email>
              <email type="domain">lamsade.dauphine.fr</email>
            </editor>
          </titleStmt>
          <editionStmt>
            <edition n="v1" type="current">
              <date type="whenSubmitted">2013-10-25 16:58:46</date>
              <date type="whenWritten">2009-04-24</date>
              <date type="whenModified">2026-02-07 05:10:27</date>
              <date type="whenReleased">2013-10-28 15:24:03</date>
              <date type="whenProduced">2009-04-24</date>
              <date type="whenEndEmbargoed">2013-10-25</date>
              <ref type="file" target="https://hal.science/hal-00877050v1/document">
                <date notBefore="2013-10-25"/>
              </ref>
              <ref type="file" subtype="author" n="1" target="https://hal.science/hal-00877050v1/file/cahier_283.pdf" id="file-877050-721203">
                <date notBefore="2013-10-25"/>
              </ref>
            </edition>
            <respStmt>
              <resp>contributor</resp>
              <name key="184561">
                <persName>
                  <forename>Eleni</forename>
                  <surname>Palaiologou</surname>
                </persName>
                <email type="md5">93d31710abe44814729d73debe8e9f2e</email>
                <email type="domain">lamsade.dauphine.fr</email>
              </name>
            </respStmt>
          </editionStmt>
          <publicationStmt>
            <distributor>CCSD</distributor>
            <idno type="halId">hal-00877050</idno>
            <idno type="halUri">https://hal.science/hal-00877050</idno>
            <idno type="halBibtex">billaut:hal-00877050</idno>
            <idno type="halRefHtml">2009</idno>
            <idno type="halRef">2009</idno>
            <availability status="restricted">
              <licence target="https://about.hal.science/hal-authorisation-v1/">HAL Authorization<ref corresp="#file-877050-721203"/></licence>
            </availability>
          </publicationStmt>
          <seriesStmt>
            <idno type="stamp" n="SHS">Sciences de l'Homme et de la Société</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="UNIV-TOURS">Université François Rabelais</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="TICE">Bibliothèque TICE</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="CNRS">CNRS - Centre national de la recherche scientifique</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="UNIV-DAUPHINE">Université Paris Dauphine - Paris IX</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="LAMSADE">Laboratoire d'analyse et modélisation de systèmes pour l'aide à la décision</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="LAMSADE-DAUPHINE" corresp="UNIV-DAUPHINE">LAMSADE (Laboratoire d'Analyse et de Modélisation des Systèmes pour l'Aide à la Décision)</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="TDS-MACS">Réseau de recherche en Théorie des Systèmes Distribués, Modélisation, Analyse et Contrôle des Systèmes</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="ROOT-TOURS" corresp="LIFAT">Équipe Recherche Opérationnelle, Ordonnancement et Transport du Laboratoire d’Informatique de l’Université de Tours</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="PSL">Université Paris sciences et lettres</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="LIFAT">Laboratoire d'Informatique Fondamentale et Appliquée de Tours</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="INSA-GROUPE">Groupe INSA</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="INSA-CVL">INSA CENTRE VAL DE LOIRE</idno>
            <idno type="stamp" n="UNIV-DAUPHINE-PSL" corresp="PSL">Université Paris Dauphine - PSL</idno>
          </seriesStmt>
          <notesStmt>
            <note type="audience" n="1">Not set</note>
          </notesStmt>
          <sourceDesc>
            <biblStruct>
              <analytic>
                <title xml:lang="en">Should you believe in the Shanghai ranking? An MCDM view</title>
                <author role="aut">
                  <persName>
                    <forename type="first">Jean-Charles</forename>
                    <surname>Billaut</surname>
                  </persName>
                  <email type="md5">a2a40e8ca3dc3579a37e3da8688c945e</email>
                  <email type="domain">univ-tours.fr</email>
                  <idno type="idhal" notation="string">jean-charles-billaut</idno>
                  <idno type="idhal" notation="numeric">5922</idno>
                  <idno type="halauthorid" notation="string">22560-5922</idno>
                  <idno type="IDREF">https://www.idref.fr/059806257</idno>
                  <idno type="ORCID">https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7938-1998</idno>
                  <orgName ref="#struct-300298"/>
                  <affiliation ref="#struct-204893"/>
                </author>
                <author role="aut">
                  <persName>
                    <forename type="first">Denis</forename>
                    <surname>Bouyssou</surname>
                  </persName>
                  <email type="md5">fa1beb245eea400ffa684d8b0e1da034</email>
                  <email type="domain">lamsade.dauphine.fr</email>
                  <idno type="idhal" notation="string">denis-bouyssou</idno>
                  <idno type="idhal" notation="numeric">182535</idno>
                  <idno type="halauthorid" notation="string">47094-182535</idno>
                  <idno type="ORCID">https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3487-8498</idno>
                  <affiliation ref="#struct-989"/>
                </author>
                <author role="aut">
                  <persName>
                    <forename type="first">Philippe</forename>
                    <surname>Vincke</surname>
                  </persName>
                  <idno type="halauthorid">103290-0</idno>
                  <affiliation ref="#struct-94476"/>
                </author>
              </analytic>
              <monogr>
                <imprint/>
              </monogr>
            </biblStruct>
          </sourceDesc>
          <profileDesc>
            <langUsage>
              <language ident="en">English</language>
            </langUsage>
            <textClass>
              <keywords scheme="author">
                <term xml:lang="en">higher education</term>
                <term xml:lang="en">Shanghai ranking</term>
                <term xml:lang="en">multiple criteria decision analysis</term>
                <term xml:lang="en">evaluation models</term>
                <term xml:lang="en">higher education.</term>
              </keywords>
              <classCode scheme="halDomain" n="info.info-ro">Computer Science [cs]/Operations Research [math.OC]</classCode>
              <classCode scheme="halDomain" n="info.info-oh">Computer Science [cs]/Other [cs.OH]</classCode>
              <classCode scheme="halDomain" n="info.info-ce">Computer Science [cs]/Computational Engineering, Finance, and Science [cs.CE]</classCode>
              <classCode scheme="halDomain" n="shs.edu">Humanities and Social Sciences/Education</classCode>
              <classCode scheme="halDomain" n="shs.gestion">Humanities and Social Sciences/Business administration</classCode>
              <classCode scheme="halTypology" n="UNDEFINED">Preprints, Working Papers, ...</classCode>
              <classCode scheme="halOldTypology" n="UNDEFINED">Preprints, Working Papers, ...</classCode>
              <classCode scheme="halTreeTypology" n="UNDEFINED">Preprints, Working Papers, ...</classCode>
            </textClass>
            <abstract xml:lang="en">
              <p>This paper proposes a critical analysis of the "Academic Ranking ofWorld Universities", published every year by the Institute of Higher Education of the Jiao Tong University in Shanghai and more commonly known as the Shanghai ranking. After having recalled how the ranking is built, we first discuss the relevance of the criteria and then analyze the proposed aggregation method. Our analysis uses tools and concepts from Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM). Our main conclusions are that the criteria that are used are not relevant, that the aggregation methodology is plagued by a number of major problems and that the whole exercise suffers from an insufficient attention paid to fundamental structuring issues. Hence, our view is that the Shanghai ranking, in spite of the media coverage it receives, does not qualify as a useful and pertinent tool to discuss the "quality" of academic institutions, let alone to guide the choice of students and family or to promote reforms of higher education systems. We outline the type of work that should be undertaken to offer sound alternatives to the Shanghai ranking.</p>
            </abstract>
          </profileDesc>
        </biblFull>
      </listBibl>
    </body>
    <back>
      <listOrg type="structures">
        <org type="laboratory" xml:id="struct-204893" status="VALID">
          <idno type="IdRef">081090722</idno>
          <idno type="RNSR">201220254T</idno>
          <idno type="ROR">https://ror.org/03r938j26</idno>
          <orgName>Laboratoire d'Informatique Fondamentale et Appliquée de Tours</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">LIFAT</orgName>
          <date type="start">2012-01-01</date>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <addrLine>64, Avenue Jean Portalis, 37200 Tours</addrLine>
              <country key="FR"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">https://lifat.univ-tours.fr/</ref>
          </desc>
          <listRelation>
            <relation name="UR6300" active="#struct-300298" type="direct"/>
            <relation active="#struct-303079" type="direct"/>
            <relation active="#struct-301232" type="indirect"/>
          </listRelation>
        </org>
        <org type="laboratory" xml:id="struct-989" status="VALID">
          <idno type="IdRef">030107156</idno>
          <idno type="ISNI">0000 0001 2097 7052</idno>
          <idno type="RNSR">201120462Y</idno>
          <idno type="ROR">https://ror.org/052bz7812</idno>
          <idno type="Wikidata">Q3214405</idno>
          <orgName>Laboratoire d'analyse et modélisation de systèmes pour l'aide à la décision</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">LAMSADE</orgName>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <addrLine>Place de Lattre de Tassigny 75775 PARIS CEDEX 16</addrLine>
              <country key="FR"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">http://www.lamsade.dauphine.fr/</ref>
          </desc>
          <listRelation>
            <relation active="#struct-300302" type="direct"/>
            <relation active="#struct-564132" type="indirect"/>
            <relation name="UMR7243 / FRE3234 / UMR7024" active="#struct-441569" type="direct"/>
          </listRelation>
        </org>
        <org type="laboratory" xml:id="struct-94476" status="INCOMING">
          <orgName>CODE</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">CODE</orgName>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <addrLine>CODE, Université Libre de bruxelles CP 210/01 Boulevard du Triomphe B-1050 Bruxelles</addrLine>
              <country key="BE"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">http://code.ulb.ac.be/code.home.php</ref>
          </desc>
          <listRelation>
            <relation active="#struct-303388" type="direct"/>
          </listRelation>
        </org>
        <org type="institution" xml:id="struct-300298" status="VALID">
          <idno type="IdRef">026404478</idno>
          <idno type="ISNI">0000000121608742</idno>
          <idno type="ROR">https://ror.org/02wwzvj46</idno>
          <orgName>Université de Tours</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">UT</orgName>
          <date type="start">1970-12-17</date>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <addrLine>60 rue du Plat d'Étain, 37020 Tours cedex 1</addrLine>
              <country key="FR"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">http://www.univ-tours.fr</ref>
          </desc>
        </org>
        <org type="institution" xml:id="struct-303079" status="VALID">
          <idno type="IdRef">203592077</idno>
          <orgName>Institut National des Sciences Appliquées - Centre Val de Loire</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">INSA CVL</orgName>
          <date type="start">2014-01-01</date>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <addrLine>88 boulevard Lahitolle, CS 60013, 18022 Bourges cedex</addrLine>
              <country key="FR"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">http://www.insa-centrevaldeloire.fr/fr/</ref>
          </desc>
          <listRelation>
            <relation active="#struct-301232" type="direct"/>
          </listRelation>
        </org>
        <org type="regroupinstitution" xml:id="struct-301232" status="VALID">
          <idno type="IdRef">162105150</idno>
          <orgName>Institut National des Sciences Appliquées</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">INSA</orgName>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <country key="FR"/>
            </address>
          </desc>
        </org>
        <org type="institution" xml:id="struct-300302" status="VALID">
          <idno type="IdRef">027787109</idno>
          <idno type="ISNI">0000000120977052</idno>
          <idno type="ROR">https://ror.org/052bz7812</idno>
          <idno type="Wikidata">Q1546437</idno>
          <orgName>Université Paris Dauphine-PSL</orgName>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <addrLine>Place du Maréchal de Lattre de Tassigny75775 PARIS Cedex 16</addrLine>
              <country key="FR"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">https://dauphine.psl.eu/</ref>
          </desc>
          <listRelation>
            <relation active="#struct-564132" type="direct"/>
          </listRelation>
        </org>
        <org type="regroupinstitution" xml:id="struct-564132" status="VALID">
          <idno type="IdRef">241597595</idno>
          <idno type="ISNI">0000 0004 1784 3645</idno>
          <idno type="ROR">https://ror.org/013cjyk83</idno>
          <orgName>Université Paris Sciences et Lettres</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">PSL</orgName>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <addrLine>60 rue Mazarine 75006 Paris</addrLine>
              <country key="FR"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">https://www.psl.eu/</ref>
          </desc>
        </org>
        <org type="regroupinstitution" xml:id="struct-441569" status="VALID">
          <idno type="IdRef">02636817X</idno>
          <idno type="ISNI">0000000122597504</idno>
          <idno type="ROR">https://ror.org/02feahw73</idno>
          <orgName>Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">CNRS</orgName>
          <date type="start">1939-10-19</date>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <country key="FR"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">https://www.cnrs.fr/</ref>
          </desc>
        </org>
        <org type="regroupinstitution" xml:id="struct-303388" status="VALID">
          <idno type="IdRef">034905812</idno>
          <idno type="ISNI">0000 0001 2348 0746</idno>
          <idno type="ROR">https://ror.org/01r9htc13</idno>
          <orgName>Université libre de Bruxelles = Free University of Brussels</orgName>
          <orgName type="acronym">ULB</orgName>
          <date type="start">1970-01-01</date>
          <desc>
            <address>
              <addrLine>Avenue Franklin Roosevelt 50 - 1050 Bruxelles</addrLine>
              <country key="BE"/>
            </address>
            <ref type="url">https://www.ulb.be/</ref>
          </desc>
        </org>
      </listOrg>
    </back>
  </text>
</TEI>