The role of nanoclay on the wear characteristics of nylon 6 nanocomposites processed via different routes is examined in this paper. Pristine clay and organoclay were used in melt-extrusion with the matrix resulting in a largely aggregated and a highly exfoliated morphology, respectively. High exfoliation of pristine clay was also achieved by a water-assist process in melt compounding. Nylon 6/pristine clay composite had the worst wear resistance due to the large aggregated clay particles. For the two nylon 6/exfoliated clay nanocomposites, the one with the organically modified clay outperformed that with the pristine clay exfoliated by water. Detailed study on the wear track and subsurface below of the nylon 6/clay composites using both transmission and scanning electron microscopy provided new insight into the differences in their deformation and damage mechanisms. It was revealed that the interfacial adhesion of clay to matrix, and not the exfoliated morphology of clay, played a critical role in wear. However, exfoliated clay morphology is preferred to aggregate morphology. Hence, the superior wear-performance of nylon 6/organoclay nanocomposite is brought about by a combined effect of fine dispersion of clay platelets in nylon 6, high interfacial interaction between nylon 6 and clay layers, and effective constraint on surrounding nylon 6 material exerted by the clay platelets.